Attorney Hüseyin Aydın · Alanya / Antalya
When a building has been declared a risky structure and the owners cannot agree on how the new building will be shared, Turkish law allows the majority to decide; the land share of an owner who does not join the decision can then be sold at public auction. But can the majority offer an owner who held a valuable unit in the old building a far less valuable unit, and have his share sold if he refuses? A 2025 decision of the Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers of the Turkish Council of State (Danıştay) gives a clear answer.
Short answer: No. In its decision E. 2023/3171, K. 2025/746 of 27.03.2025, the Plenary Session held that even where the quorum was met, notifications were served and a valuation report was obtained, a sale based on an allocation that is manifestly inequitable violates the right to property and must be annulled. According to the Plenary Session, paying the market value of the land share does not compensate for the loss of value arising from location, such as a street-front ground-floor shop.
Important: Administrative acts taken under Law No. 6306 can be challenged before the administrative courts within thirty days of notification. If the sale is completed and the share is transferred to a third party, it may not be possible to re-register the share in the former owner’s name even after annulment. A stay of execution should therefore be requested before the sale takes place.
This guide has been prepared on the basis of Law No. 6306 on the Transformation of Areas under Disaster Risk, the Implementing Regulation of Law No. 6306, Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, decisions of the Constitutional Court, the Council of State, the regional administrative courts and the Court of Cassation, and doctrinal views published in Turkish law journals.
Contents
The Decision and a Correction of the Social Media Summary
The decision has been widely shared on social media in the following form: “an owner with two street-front shops was offered shops at the back, not at street level; with a 51% majority his shops were put up for sale; the court annulled the sale”. The summary captures the spirit of the decision but needs three technical corrections:
- Majority: The decision was not taken by 51% but by a 46/48 share ratio, exceeding even the two-thirds quorum in force at the time. The simple majority rule was introduced by Law No. 7471 in November 2023; the events predate it.
- Authority that sold the share: The shares were not put up for sale by the other owners; the sale decision was taken by the Provincial Directorate of Environment and Urbanisation upon the majority owner’s application, and the lawsuit was filed against that administrative act.
- Court that annulled: The sale was annulled by the insistence decision of the regional administrative court; the Council of State Plenary Session upheld it by majority vote, and the annulment became final.
Legal Framework: Article 6 of Law No. 6306
Law No. 6306 leaves the redevelopment of the plot on which a risky structure stands primarily to the owners. Departing from the unanimity rule in Article 692 of the Turkish Civil Code and Article 45 of the Condominium Law, it allows decisions on reconstruction, flat-for-land or revenue-sharing arrangements and the sale of shares to be taken by a majority calculated according to the owners’ shares.
Development of the quorum
After the 2016 amendment, Article 6(1) required at least a two-thirds majority. Article 10 of Law No. 7471 of 07.11.2023 (Official Gazette 09.11.2023/32364) reduced this to a simple (absolute) majority. Since the events in the case took place between 2019 and 2021, the two-thirds quorum applied. The principle established by the decision, however, has become far more important now that the quorum has been lowered.
The sale mechanism
Under the current text, the land shares of owners who do not join the majority decision are sold by public auction to the other owners who have agreed, at not less than the market value determined on behalf of the Urban Transformation Presidency. For risky structures, the sale is repeated until a sale is made to agreeing owners or to third parties who accept the agreement. The decision and the offer containing its terms are notified to non-participating owners through a notary or by a fifteen-day posting at the neighbourhood headman’s office; if the offer is not accepted within fifteen days, the share will be sold.
What happens if the sale is annulled?
Provisions added by Laws No. 7410 and 7471 distinguish two situations:
| Ground for annulment | Statutory consequence |
|---|---|
| Grounds other than an incorrectly calculated price (e.g. an inequitable allocation) | If the share has not been transferred to a third party or made impossible to re-register, it is re-registered ex officio in the former owner’s name; a statutory mortgage is established in favour of the buyer until the price is refunded. |
| Only an incorrectly calculated price | The share does not return; the difference is paid to the former owner by the owner who bought the share. |
This distinction directly shapes litigation strategy: if the aim is to recover the property, the annulment should be based on a ground other than price, in particular the inequitable nature of the allocation.
The Council of State Decision: Facts, Proceedings and Reasoning
Facts
The dispute concerned a 557.94 m² plot in Kdz. Ereğli, Zonguldak. A 2/48 share (two ground-floor shops) belonged to the claimants and a 46/48 share to the intervening owner. The building was declared a risky structure and demolished.
The majority owner signed a notarised flat-for-land construction contract with a contractor. Instead of their ground-floor shops facing a busy main street, the contract allocated to the claimants two shops at the rear of the new building, on the 3rd floor. At a meeting on 18.10.2019 the construction was approved by the 46/48 share; when the claimants did not sign, the Provincial Directorate decided to sell their shares by auction. The sale took place on 20.01.2021 and the shares were sold to the intervening owner for TRY 379,200.00.
Proceedings
| Stage | Court and outcome | Main reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| First instance | Administrative Court: dismissed | The contract was served with a notice and the claimants did not sign; the act complied with Art. 15/A of the Regulation. |
| Appeal | Regional Administrative Court: act annulled | No formal defect, but the allocation was manifestly inequitable without the need for technical examination; the right to property was violated. |
| Cassation | Council of State 6th Chamber, E. 2022/8923, K. 2023/3634, 11.04.2023: reversed | The allocation is a decision between private persons; the civil case could be awaited as a preliminary issue, or an on-site inspection and expert examination should be carried out. |
| Insistence | Regional Administrative Court: insisted on its first decision | The expert report in the civil court file also found a threefold difference in location value between the old and new position. |
| Appeal against insistence | Council of State Plenary Session: upheld (majority, final) | See below. |
Reasoning of the Plenary Session
The Plenary Session based its assessment on the Constitutional Court’s Plenary judgment in the application of Hanife Yıldız Torum and Nimet Filiz Seven (App. No. 2018/1567, 10.02.2022). In that judgment, the Constitutional Court held that an administrative court confining itself to a merely formal review does not provide the review required by the right to property: reviewing the lawfulness of the sale also requires examining whether the owners’ refusal of the new allocation had a justified basis, and a review carried out without examining whether the new allocation is balanced and fair cannot be regarded as genuine judicial review (§ 106).
The Plenary Session found that the 6th Chamber’s approach would leave the dispute unresolved, since the civil court had itself stayed its case pending the administrative case without examining the allocation. It therefore examined the fairness of the allocation in the case itself and found that there was a large difference in value between units facing the rear and those facing the busy main street; that this difference could not be remedied even by paying the claimants the value of their share in the plot; and that the inequitable nature of the allocation was clear from the allocation sketch and photographs without any technical examination.
The Plenary Session also stressed that, through the sale, the claimants, small shareholders in a valuable street-front position, would be reduced to ordinary small shareholders receiving only the value of their land share rather than the value of their former property. It concluded that a sale based on an allocation that manifestly violates the right to property is unlawful.
Dissenting opinions
- First dissent: The administration has no power or duty to examine whether the contract is fair; doing so would conflict with the Law’s aim of fixed time limits and procedures; in any event there was no gross imbalance.
- Second dissent: The decision should have been reversed in line with the 6th Chamber’s reasoning.
- Third dissent: The civil action for annulment and adaptation of the contract should have been awaited as a preliminary issue before examining the merits.
The Wider Case Law
Since the Constitutional Court’s 2022 judgment, administrative case law tying the lawfulness of the sale to the fairness of the allocation has clearly strengthened, while the opposing view survives in dissenting opinions.
| Decision | Subject | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Council of State Plenary Session, E. 2023/3171, K. 2025/746, 27.03.2025 | Rear 3rd-floor shops offered instead of street-front ground-floor shops | Annulment of the sale upheld (majority) |
| Council of State 4th Chamber, E. 2024/2020, K. 2025/1915, 24.03.2025 | Retrial after the Constitutional Court judgment: 2 offices in the basement and side façade offered instead of 4 street-front shops and 1 flat | Annulment based on expert examination upheld (majority) |
| Council of State 4th Chamber, E. 2024/3830, K. 2025/1918, 24.03.2025 | Sale below market value and inequitable allocation | Annulment upheld (majority) |
| İzmir Regional Administrative Court, 3rd Chamber, E. 2026/206, K. 2026/348, 25.02.2026 | Sale of a share in a risky structure | An offer with manifest imbalances cannot be imposed; even with a fair allocation, the share cannot be sold below market value |
| Court of Cassation 5th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/5340, K. 2025/17510, 16.12.2025 | Annulment of a co-owners’ decision | Dismissal without on-site inspection and expert report reversed |
| Court of Cassation 3rd Civil Chamber, E. 2018/4855, K. 2019/8655, 04.11.2019 | Allocation of units in the new building | Location, floor and size should be preserved as far as appropriate; otherwise unjust enrichment arises |
In the two 4th Chamber decisions, the dissenting member argued that the administration conducting the sale has no power to review the content of a majority decision to which it is not a party and that objections can only be examined in the civil courts. In all three Council of State decisions, however, the majority decided the other way, in favour of a fairness review.
The case law today can be summarised in three propositions:
- In an action against the sale, the administrative court must examine whether the allocation is fair and economically balanced; a merely formal review is not enough.
- Where the imbalance is obvious, the court may decide on the basis of the sketch and photographs without technical examination; in disputed cases, on-site inspection and expert examination are essential.
- Payment of market value does not compensate for the loss of value arising from location, façade and level.
Doctrinal Views
Turkish scholars criticise not so much the majority rule itself as its use as a tool for depriving the minority of their property.
- Limits of the majority’s power: Turgut Öz argues that the content of the majority decision is limited by the purpose of the Law and that a decision disproportionately reducing the minority’s share cannot enjoy legal protection even if the quorum is met. Mahmut Alper Kılıç stresses that owners must exercise this power in good faith (Art. 2 of the Civil Code).
- The quorum debate: The prevailing view is that only a majority of shares is required; a minority view proposes that a majority of owners should also be required. The Council of State case illustrates the concern: a single owner holding 46/48 had signed the contract in advance and then approved his own decision at the meeting. Kılıç notes that protection can only be achieved through judicial review, not by raising the quorum.
- Judicial review as a requirement: Özkan Özyakışır argues that, under Articles 13 and 35 of the Constitution, the interference can only be proportionate if the allocation is subject to judicial review; floor, façade and location should be preserved as far as possible or an equitable justification given; a decision and contract based on an inequitable allocation are null and void under Art. 27 of the Code of Obligations.
- Owners forced to sign: Kılıç argues that an owner who signs an unfavourable contract under reservation to avoid the sale of his share may bring an unjust enrichment claim against the other owners if the increase in value was distributed disproportionately, subject to the two-year limitation period in Art. 82 of the Code of Obligations.
Practical Consequences
For owners who do not join the decision
- Do not miss the deadline: file an action in the administrative courts within thirty days of notification of the sale decision or sale notice, and request a stay of execution.
- Do not stay silent: within the fifteen-day notification period, explain in a reasoned notarised notice why the offer is inequitable.
- Document the old and new position: collect title deeds, project plans, photographs and lease agreements showing the floor, façade, level, size and use of the former unit.
- Request an expert examination on the fairness of the allocation in the administrative case; an administrative action against the sale and a civil action against the majority decision are not mutually exclusive.
- Frame the claim correctly: if you want the property back, rely on the inequitable allocation; an annulment based only on price leads to payment of the difference, not return of the share.
- If you had to sign, do so under express reservation of your rights.
For majority owners and contractors
- Propose an allocation based on the previous position; if features such as street frontage, ground floor or commercial use cannot be preserved, compensate the difference and give written reasons.
- Obtain a licensed valuation comparing the old and new units, not only the land share.
- Negotiate and document the negotiations; presenting the minority with a contract already signed before the meeting was viewed unfavourably in both the Council of State and Constitutional Court cases.
- A sale based on an inequitable allocation may be annulled years later, creating serious legal uncertainty at the condominium, sales and financing stages.
Related guides: Your Building Has Been Declared a Risky Structure and Conditions for Administrative Termination of Contracts in Urban Transformation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my land share be sold if I do not join the urban transformation decision?
Yes. Under Law No. 6306, the land share of an owner who does not join a decision taken by a simple majority of shares may be sold at public auction to the agreeing owners at not less than market value. However, if the allocation on which the sale is based is manifestly inequitable, the sale can be annulled.
What can I do if I am offered a less valuable unit in the new building?
According to Council of State Plenary Session decision E. 2023/3171, K. 2025/746, the administrative court must examine whether the allocation is fair and economically balanced. In cases of manifest imbalance, such as offering a rear upper-floor unit instead of a street-front ground-floor unit, the sale can be annulled.
What is the time limit for challenging the sale?
Under Article 6(9) of Law No. 6306, administrative acts taken under the Law can be challenged within thirty days of notification. Requesting a stay of execution before the sale is important.
Will I get my share back if the sale is annulled?
If the sale is annulled on a ground other than an incorrectly calculated price and the share has not been transferred to a third party, it is re-registered in the former owner’s name. If annulled only because the price was too low, the share does not return; the difference is paid to the former owner.
Conclusion
The Council of State Plenary Session decision of 27.03.2025 confirms that the majority rule in urban transformation is a decision-making method, not a power to devalue the minority’s property. This principle has become even more important since the quorum was lowered from two-thirds to a simple majority: a single owner holding more than half of the shares, or a small group that has agreed with a contractor, can now decide alone. The dissenting opinions and the preliminary-issue debate show that consistent case law is still needed and that the forum and procedure for examining objections to the allocation should be clearly regulated by law. To avoid losing your rights in a specific dispute, it is advisable to consult a lawyer experienced in this field.
Sources: Law No. 6306, Art. 6; Implementing Regulation of Law No. 6306, Arts. 15, 15/A; Council of State Plenary Session E. 2023/3171 K. 2025/746; Council of State 6th Chamber E. 2022/8923 K. 2023/3634; Constitutional Court, Hanife Yıldız Torum and Nimet Filiz Seven, App. No. 2018/1567 (Official Gazette 09.03.2022/31773) and the decisions listed in the table above. Doctrine: Çakır/Ülker, MÜHF-HAD, Vol. 27, No. 2, 2021, pp. 1066-1106 (DergiPark); Kılıç, SDÜHFD, Vol. 15, No. 2, 2025, pp. 2069-2107 (DergiPark); Özyakışır, EBYÜ-HFD, Vol. 29, No. 1, 2025, pp. 459-493 (DergiPark); Öz, İKÜHFD, Vol. 15, No. 1, 2016 (cited indirectly). Legislation texts: mevzuat.gov.tr.
Legal Notice: This text has been prepared for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. sophoshukuk.com makes no referral, guarantee or promise of outcome. Each case must be assessed on its own particular circumstances; for your specific dispute, please obtain professional advice from a lawyer.