Attorney Hüseyin Aydın · Alanya / Antalya
One sibling has been living alone for years in the family flat in Alanya; only one heir spends the holidays in the summer house in Mahmutlar; one co-owner harvests the orchard in Gazipaşa; or the share of heirs living abroad is being let out by someone else. In each case the other co-owners ask the same question: can I claim compensation for the use of my share?
Short answer: A person who uses real property without a legal basis can be ordered to pay ecrimisil (compensation for unlawful occupation) for the rental loss suffered by the owner. Between co-owners, however, the general rule is that the exclusion-from-use requirement (intifadan men) must first be met, meaning the claimant must notify the occupying co-owner that they wish to use the property; in some cases this requirement does not apply. Ecrimisil claims are subject to a 5-year limitation period counted backwards from the date the lawsuit is filed.
Important: If you plan to claim ecrimisil, send the co-owner using the property a notarised warning letter stating that you wish to use it. The notice is the safest way to prove the date on which the exclusion requirement was met; ecrimisil can only be claimed for the period after that date.
This guide has been prepared for inherited flats, villas, orchards and fields in Alanya, Antalya, Gazipaşa, Manavgat, Mahmutlar and Konaklı on the basis of Article 995 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, the Court of Cassation’s Unification of Case Law Decision No. 29/10 of 25.05.1938 and decisions of the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation.
Contents
Anahtar terimler · Key terms · Ключевые термины · واژههای کلیدی
| Türkçe | English | Русский | فارسی |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ecrimisil | compensation for unlawful occupation (mesne profits) | компенсация за незаконное пользование | اجرتالمثل |
| Paydaş / paylı mülkiyet | co-owner / co-ownership | долевой собственник / долевая собственность | شریک / مالکیت مشاعی |
| İntifadan men | exclusion from use (prior notice) | лишение права пользования (уведомление) | منع از انتفاع |
| Zamanaşımı | limitation period | срок исковой давности | مرور زمان |
| El atmanın önlenmesi | action to stop interference | иск об устранении препятствий | دعوای رفع تصرف |
| Alanya gayrimenkul avukatı | Alanya real estate lawyer | адвокат по недвижимости в Аланье | وکیل املاک در آلانیا |
1. What Is Ecrimisil?
Ecrimisil is the compensation that a bad-faith possessor who uses real property without the owner’s permission or any legal basis must pay to the owner. Its statutory basis is Article 995 of the Turkish Civil Code, under which a possessor not acting in good faith must compensate the rightful holder for the damage caused and for the fruits obtained or negligently not obtained.
The owner does not need to prove an actual loss; ecrimisil is calculated on the basis of the market rental value of the property. It can be thought of as the “rent” for an unlawfully occupied property, but since there is no lease between the parties, its legal nature is compensation.
2. The Exclusion-from-Use Requirement Between Co-Owners
In inherited or jointly purchased property, every co-owner has the right to use every part of the property. For this reason, according to the Court of Cassation, co-owners generally cannot claim ecrimisil from each other unless they have been excluded from use. The requirement is met when the claimant co-owner notifies the occupying co-owner that they wish to benefit from the property or its income, and it can be proven by any means of evidence (Court of Cassation, 7th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/1721, K. 2025/125, 09.01.2025).
The Court of Cassation does not require exclusion from use where:
- the property is public property;
- the property yields natural fruits (such as an olive grove or citrus orchard) or generates rental income;
- the occupying co-owner claims the entire property and denies the others’ shares;
- a use agreement between the co-owners specifies the part each will use;
- the claimant has previously filed an action to prevent interference, a partition action or an ecrimisil action, or initiated enforcement proceedings, regarding the same property;
- a business established by the deceased or generating income in itself is occupied.
Seasonally let summer flats and citrus orchards in Alanya fall within these exceptions, so ecrimisil can be claimed for them even without a prior notice. If a partition action has been filed, service of the statement of claim may also count as exclusion from use. See our partition action guide on this.
3. Limitation: 5 Years Backwards
Under the Court of Cassation’s Unification of Case Law Decision No. 29/10 of 25.05.1938 and settled case law, ecrimisil claims are subject to a five-year limitation period counted backwards from the filing date (Court of Cassation, 7th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/4266, K. 2024/5195, 21.11.2024). For example, a lawsuit filed in 2026 can go back no further than 2021; earlier periods are time-barred.
Between co-owners, however, ecrimisil can only be claimed for the period after the exclusion date. So if a sibling has used the flat since 2015 and was sent a notice in 2024, a lawsuit filed in 2026 can claim ecrimisil only for the period after 2024.
4. How Is Ecrimisil Calculated?
The court carries out an on-site inspection and, through an expert, determines the market rental value of the property for each period. The calculation takes into account:
- the type (residence, business premises, orchard, field), location and size of the property;
- rents of comparable properties during the period in question;
- increases for subsequent years using indices such as CPI or PPI;
- crop yield for agricultural land;
- the claimant’s share in the property.
Example: an heir holding a 1/4 share in a flat in Kestel with a market rent of TRY 25,000 per month, who sent a notice to their sibling at the beginning of 2024 and sued at the beginning of 2026, can claim approximately 25,000 × 24 × 1/4 = TRY 150,000 in ecrimisil for the two-year period (annual rent increases are calculated separately).
5. The Lawsuit and Claims That Can Be Combined
An ecrimisil lawsuit is filed at the civil court of first instance where the property is located. In the same lawsuit, the claimant can also request that interference with their share be prevented. If the property has been let and the rental income has been collected by one co-owner alone, payment of the share of the rental income can be claimed instead of or in addition to ecrimisil.
Ecrimisil and partition actions often go together: the partition action leads to the sale or division of the property, while the ecrimisil action compensates for its use until the sale. Remember that mediation is a precondition for filing a partition action.
6. Notes for Foreign Heirs
In Alanya, many properties pass from a Turkish testator to children living abroad, or to the heirs of foreigners who owned property in Turkey. Heirs living abroad can grant a power of attorney to a lawyer in Turkey, who can send the warning letter and file the ecrimisil lawsuit. First, a certificate of inheritance must be obtained and the transfer registered at the land registry. See our guide to foreigners’ inheritance rights.
7. Ecrimisil in Academic Research
Because ecrimisil is not expressly regulated in Turkish statutes and has been shaped largely by case law, it is examined in detail in academic research as well. A doctoral thesis entitled simply “Ecrimisil” in the National Thesis Centre of the Council of Higher Education (YÖK) analyses it as the liability arising from a bad-faith possessor’s use of property unlawfully withheld. In separate chapters it examines the conditions and legal nature of ecrimisil, cases involving a contractual relationship or acquisitive prescription, its relationship with other claims such as prevention of interference, and finally calculation, interest, limitation and the lawsuit itself (Çaldağ, 2025, Thesis No. 927898).
As regards ecrimisil between co-owners, a master’s thesis on the protection of shares in co-ownership draws an important distinction: for divisible interests such as ecrimisil, each co-owner can protect their own share alone under Article 688/3 of the Civil Code, while for indivisible common interests protection can be sought for the benefit of all co-owners and for the whole property under Article 693/3 (Şahin, 2025, Thesis No. 969373). This is why an heir can file an ecrimisil lawsuit for their own share without the participation of the other heirs, and why the calculation example above is based on a 1/4 share.
Conclusion
Ecrimisil is one of the most effective claims available to an owner against a person who uses property unlawfully. Between co-owners, exclusion from use is generally required, so sending a notarised warning letter is essential. For let or fruit-bearing properties, no notice is required. The lawsuit can cover at most the five years preceding the filing date.
Given the technical details of calculation and proof, it is advisable to consult a lawyer specialised in this field to resolve your dispute and avoid losing your rights.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is ecrimisil?
Ecrimisil is the compensation that a bad-faith possessor who uses property without the owner’s permission must pay to the owner. It is calculated on the basis of the market rental value of the property.
My sibling uses the inherited home. Can I claim rent from them?
Yes, but as a rule you must first notify your sibling that you wish to use the property, i.e. meet the exclusion-from-use requirement. Ecrimisil can be claimed for the period after this notice.
When is exclusion from use not required?
It is not required if the property is let and generates income, yields natural fruits, the occupying co-owner denies the others’ shares, or a lawsuit such as a partition action has already been filed.
How many years back can ecrimisil be claimed?
Ecrimisil claims are subject to a 5-year limitation period counted backwards from the filing date. Between co-owners, ecrimisil cannot be claimed for the period before the exclusion date.
How is ecrimisil calculated?
The court carries out an on-site inspection and an expert determines the market rental value of the property. This value is applied according to the claimant’s share and the relevant periods.
Which court hears an ecrimisil lawsuit?
The civil court of first instance where the property is located. Prevention of interference can also be requested in the same lawsuit.
Sources: Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, Art. 995; Court of Cassation Unification of Case Law Decision 25.05.1938, 29/10; Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers 27.02.2002, E. 2002/3-131, K. 2002/114; Court of Cassation 7th Civil Chamber E. 2024/1721 K. 2025/125; E. 2024/4266 K. 2024/5195; E. 2023/5469 K. 2024/4232; E. 2024/3777 K. 2024/5384; YÖK National Thesis Centre, Nos. 927898, 969373. Legislation texts: mevzuat.gov.tr.
Legal Notice: This text has been prepared for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. sophoshukuk.com makes no referral, guarantee or promise of outcome. Each case must be assessed on its own particular circumstances; for your specific dispute, please obtain professional advice from a lawyer.