Attorney Hüseyin Aydın · Alanya / Antalya
A tenant who constantly fights, makes noise late into the night, insults other residents or damages the building door is a serious problem for both the landlord and the neighbours. Many landlords react by sending a short notice and filing an eviction lawsuit straight away. However, Article 316 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK) sets a strict procedure, and a lawsuit filed without following it can be dismissed even if the breach really happened.
Short answer: In residential and roofed business leases, evicting a tenant who disturbs the neighbours or damages the property for breach of contract generally requires a written notice giving the tenant at least thirty days to remedy the breach and warning that the lease will otherwise be terminated, and the breach must still continue at the end of that period. Immediate termination without a grace period is only possible where the tenant intentionally causes serious damage, where granting time would clearly be pointless, or where the tenant’s conduct has become unbearable. A single family argument or limited damage does not open this exceptional route.
Important: Giving the tenant less than thirty days in the notice, such as 3, 7, 10 or 15 days, is treated by the Court of Cassation and the Regional Courts of Appeal as sufficient on its own for the eviction lawsuit to be dismissed. As a rule, the defect is not cured even if more than thirty days have passed by the time the lawsuit is filed.
This guide has been prepared on the basis of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, the Condominium Law No. 634, the Law No. 6325 on Mediation in Civil Disputes, a 2026 decision of the 15th Civil Chamber of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal and the case law of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay).
Contents
- Article 316 TBK: Duty of Care and Respect for Neighbours
- The Rule: A 30-Day Notice
- The Exception: Immediate Termination
- The Ankara Regional Court of Appeal Decision
- Why a Family Argument or a One-Off Incident Is Not Enough
- Evidence: What Counts?
- Mediation, Competent Court and Procedure
- The Route for Neighbours and Site Management: Article 33 KMK
- Defence Points for the Tenant
- Comparison Table
- Summary of Decisions
- Frequently Asked Questions
Article 316 TBK: Duty of Care and Respect for Neighbours
Article 316 TBK imposes two separate duties on the tenant: to use the leased property carefully and in accordance with the contract, and to show due respect to the other occupants of the building and to the neighbours. The tenant’s behaviour in the apartment block or residential complex is therefore part of the lease relationship, not only the condition of the flat itself. Situations once described as “manifestly improper use” under the former Code of Obligations No. 818 are now assessed under Article 316.
The article has three layers:
- Paragraph 1: sets out the duty of care and respect.
- Paragraph 2: in residential and roofed business leases, the landlord must give the tenant at least thirty days in writing to remedy the breach, warning that the lease will otherwise be terminated. In other leases, the landlord may terminate immediately without prior warning.
- Paragraph 3: even in residential and roofed business leases, the landlord may terminate immediately by written notice if the tenant intentionally causes serious damage to the property, if granting a period would clearly be pointless, or if the tenant’s conduct has become unbearable for the landlord, other occupants or neighbours.
The Rule: A 30-Day Notice
Most mistakes in practice are made at this stage. For a breach-of-contract eviction lawsuit to succeed, the notice must contain all of the following:
- It must be in writing (sending it through a notary is preferred for ease of proof),
- The breach must be described specifically,
- The tenant must be given at least thirty days to remedy the breach,
- It must clearly state that the lease will be terminated if the breach is not remedied in time,
- The breach must still continue at the end of that period.
The Court of Cassation holds that a notice lacking any of these elements produces no legal effect:
- Three days: In Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2014/1761, K. 2014/2333, 03.03.2014, the notice gave the tenant three days, so it was held that the notice “produces no legal consequence”.
- Seven days: In Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2015/9355, K. 2016/1457, 29.02.2016, the first-instance court ordered eviction because the lawsuit was filed 35 days after the notice and the breach had still not been remedied. The Court of Cassation reversed, holding that because only seven days had been given, the conditions for filing the lawsuit were not met. The decision shows that a short period cannot be cured by the passage of time.
- Fifteen days: In Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2015/6262, K. 2015/9345, 03.11.2015 and E. 2013/12206, K. 2013/13831, 09.10.2013, notices giving 15 days were found not to comply with Article 316.
- No period at all: In Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2013/14216, K. 2013/15789, 25.11.2013, a notice listing the breaches one by one but giving no time to remedy them was characterised as a “unilateral termination notice”, and it was held that the lawsuit should have been dismissed.
- Thirty days to vacate: In Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2014/9652, K. 2014/11799, 03.11.2014, giving thirty days to vacate the property, instead of thirty days to remedy the breach, was held not to comply with Article 316(2).
Note: “Vacate the flat within thirty days” and “remedy the breach within thirty days, otherwise the lease will be terminated” are legally different statements. The Court of Cassation requires the second.
The Exception: Immediate Termination
Article 316(3) allows the landlord to terminate immediately by written notice in serious cases where a thirty-day period would be meaningless. In its decision E. 2017/1770, K. 2021/1738, 23.12.2021, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation explained that the former “manifestly improper use” cases are now regulated in Article 316(3), and that where the tenant’s conduct is unbearable the landlord may terminate the lease immediately by written notice.
Examples where the Court of Cassation found the threshold of unbearableness to be met:
- Serious threats and swearing directed at the landlord: In Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2015/8992, K. 2016/308, 25.01.2016, a dispute from Gazipaşa, the tenant told the landlord “I will break your arms and wings” and used abusive language, supported by witness statements in a criminal file. This was described as the “principal evidence” that the lease had become unbearable, and the dismissal was reversed. Similarly, in E. 2015/3105, K. 2016/396, 26.01.2016, death threats against the landlord were accepted as grounds of unbearableness.
- Threats against residents of the complex: In Court of Cassation 3rd Civil Chamber, E. 2017/4988, K. 2017/12944, 28.09.2017, based on witness statements that the tenant threatened residents, the lease was held to have become unbearable and a lawsuit could be filed without prior notice.
- Pouring dirty water into common areas and insults: In Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2015/2255, K. 2015/3766, 15.04.2015, the first-instance court had dismissed the case because the neighbours had not complained to the authorities. The Court of Cassation reversed, stressing that Article 316 does not require the conduct to be a criminal offence under the Turkish Penal Code; it is enough that it has become unbearable for the landlord or neighbours.
- Unlicensed construction and persistence: In Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2015/10963, K. 2016/3835, 11.05.2016, the tenant’s unlicensed construction of a closed area and terrace on the top floor, the sealing of the building by the municipality and the tenant’s persistence were assessed under Article 316(3).
The Ankara Regional Court of Appeal Decision
A recent example is the decision of the 15th Civil Chamber of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal (BAM), E. 2026/18, K. 2026/2687.
The Facts
The defendant was a tenant under a lease dated 15.01.2020. The landlord filed an eviction lawsuit under Article 316, alleging that the tenant constantly fought and disturbed the surroundings and damaged the door of the property. In the notice sent before the lawsuit, instead of the statutory thirty days, the tenant was given ten days to repair all damage and restore the property. The first-instance court dismissed the case and the landlord appealed.
The Court’s Reasoning
The Chamber dismissed the appeal on the merits. The reasoning rests on three points:
- The notice gave ten days instead of thirty, so the ordinary termination procedure under Article 316(2) was not properly followed.
- The file contained no serious damage or fault that would justify extraordinary termination without a grace period. In particular, damage to the apartment door caused during a family argument was not considered a ground for extraordinary termination under Article 316(3).
- There were no incident reports or similar records; the allegation of “constant fighting” was not supported by concrete evidence.
The decision clearly shows a common mistake made by landlords: a lawsuit based on a notice with too short a period can only be saved if the facts fall within one of the serious cases in Article 316(3). If they do not, failing to give thirty days is enough to lose the case.
Why a Family Argument or a One-Off Incident Is Not Enough
The approach of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal is consistent with earlier case law. In Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2013/10719, K. 2013/12541, 17.09.2013, concerning a tenant and family who allegedly shouted during domestic arguments and watched television loudly, the Court held:
- The reports relied on by the landlord stated generally that the tenant “disturbed the neighbours in every respect” and contained no concrete information.
- The family arguments of the tenant and his family mentioned by the witnesses were not a reason serious enough to justify eviction.
The eviction ordered by the first-instance court was therefore reversed. The criterion emerging from the case law is a distinction between the noise and friction that must be tolerated to some extent in apartment life and conduct that is repeated, intentional, directed at others and makes communal living practically impossible. Immediate termination requires the second type, proven with concrete evidence.
Evidence: What Counts?
The Ankara decision expressly mentions the absence of incident reports. In practice, the following evidence is decisive:
- Police reports and criminal investigation or prosecution files: among the strongest evidence for threats, insults or damage to property. However, the Court of Cassation does not require the conduct to be a crime.
- Reports by the building or complex management stating the date, time and incident: general reports without concrete incidents are not considered sufficient.
- Witness statements: statements of neighbours and complex staff are important. The fact that a witness is also a tenant of the landlord does not by itself make the statement worthless; it must be assessed together with the rest of the file.
- Proof of damage: photographs, site inspection or a court-ordered preservation of evidence through the civil court of peace.
- Audio and video recordings: may be taken into account if lawfully obtained; care should be taken with recordings that infringe personal rights.
Mediation, Competent Court and Procedure
- Mandatory mediation: Since 01.09.2023, under Article 18/B of Law No. 6325, applying to a mediator before filing a lawsuit is mandatory in disputes arising from lease relationships. Eviction through summary enforcement proceedings under the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law is outside this scope, but an eviction lawsuit for breach of contract is subject to mediation.
- Competent court: Under Article 4/1-a of the Code of Civil Procedure, eviction lawsuits arising from lease relationships are heard by the civil court of peace (sulh hukuk mahkemesi). For a property in Alanya, Gazipaşa or Manavgat, the case is generally heard by the civil court of peace in the relevant district.
- Order of steps: first a thirty-day notice (or, in serious cases, an immediate termination notice), then a mediation application after the period expires, and an eviction lawsuit if no agreement is reached.
- If the tenant remedies the breach: if the breach is remedied within thirty days (for example, the damage is repaired and the disturbing behaviour stops), an eviction claim based on Article 316(2) loses its basis.
The Route for Neighbours and Site Management: Article 33 KMK
Only the landlord can file an eviction lawsuit under Article 316. Disturbed neighbours or the management of the complex may instead request judicial intervention (hakimin müdahalesi) against the tenant under Articles 18 and 33 of the Condominium Law. The duty under the Condominium Law to act in good faith and not to disturb one another also applies to tenants living in the units.
In the case decided by the Court of Cassation 5th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/12848, K. 2026/8824, 11.05.2026, the building manager sought eviction and judicial intervention because of the tenant’s threats, insults and noise. The first-instance court rejected eviction but ordered that the tenant be warned under Article 33 not to insult or threaten residents, bang on walls or disturb people at night. As the tenant moved out during the proceedings, the Regional Court of Appeal held that the case had become moot but ordered the tenant to bear the costs since the claimant had been right; the Court of Cassation upheld this decision.
This route can be a practical solution particularly in large residential complexes in Alanya, Mahmutlar, Kestel and Konaklı, where short-term and long-term tenants live side by side. Where the landlord is reluctant to sue, a warning order under Article 33 and continued misconduct despite it can later be strong evidence in an Article 316 lawsuit filed by the landlord.
Defence Points for the Tenant
- Whether the period in the notice was shorter than thirty days, and whether it was given to remedy the breach or simply to vacate,
- Whether the notice was duly served,
- Whether the breach was remedied within the period (repair of the damage, end of the disturbance),
- Whether the alleged incidents were one-off or repeated,
- Whether the reports relied on contain a specific incident, date and time,
- Whether the mandatory mediation requirement was fulfilled before the lawsuit.
Comparison Table
| Route | Legal basis | Who applies? | Condition | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Termination after notice | Art. 316(2) TBK | Landlord | Written notice with at least 30 days; breach continues after the period | Eviction |
| Immediate termination | Art. 316(3) TBK | Landlord | Intentional serious damage, pointless period or unbearableness; written notice | Eviction |
| Judicial intervention | Arts. 18, 33 KMK | Unit owners, manager, other residents | Proof of disturbing conduct | Warning; administrative fine if it continues |
Summary of Decisions
| Court / Reference | Subject | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Ankara BAM 15th CC, E. 2026/18, K. 2026/2687 | 10-day notice; door damaged during a family argument | Appeal dismissed; dismissal upheld |
| Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1770, K. 2021/1738, 23.12.2021 | Art. 316(3) and former “manifestly improper use” | Immediate termination if unbearable |
| Court of Cassation 6th CC, E. 2015/9355, K. 2016/1457, 29.02.2016 | 7-day notice; lawsuit filed 35 days later | Eviction reversed |
| Court of Cassation 6th CC, E. 2014/1761, K. 2014/2333, 03.03.2014 | 3-day notice | Notice has no legal effect |
| Court of Cassation 6th CC, E. 2015/6262, K. 2015/9345, 03.11.2015 | 15-day notice | Eviction reversed |
| Court of Cassation 6th CC, E. 2013/14216, K. 2013/15789, 25.11.2013 | Termination notice without a period | Eviction reversed |
| Court of Cassation 6th CC, E. 2013/10719, K. 2013/12541, 17.09.2013 | Family arguments, vague reports | Eviction reversed |
| Court of Cassation 6th CC, E. 2015/8992, K. 2016/308, 25.01.2016 | Threats and swearing at the landlord | Dismissal reversed; unbearableness accepted |
| Court of Cassation 6th CC, E. 2015/2255, K. 2015/3766, 15.04.2015 | Dirty water in common areas, insults; no crime required | Dismissal reversed |
| Court of Cassation 3rd CC, E. 2017/4988, K. 2017/12944, 28.09.2017 | Threats against residents | Lawsuit possible without notice; dismissal reversed |
| Court of Cassation 5th CC, E. 2025/12848, K. 2026/8824, 11.05.2026 | Art. 33 KMK judicial intervention against a tenant | BAM decision upheld |
Frequently Asked Questions
How many days must the tenant be given?
In residential and roofed business leases, at least thirty days must be given to remedy the breach. Notices with a shorter period are treated by the Court of Cassation as having no legal effect, and the eviction lawsuit is dismissed.
My tenant damaged the building door. Can I evict immediately?
As a rule, no. The Ankara Regional Court of Appeal did not consider damage to the apartment door during a family argument to be a serious ground for extraordinary termination. Immediate termination requires intentional serious damage or unbearable conduct.
Does the tenant’s conduct have to be a crime?
No. The Court of Cassation does not require the conduct to be a criminal offence under the Turkish Penal Code; it is enough that it has become unbearable for the landlord or the neighbours.
Is mediation mandatory before an eviction lawsuit?
Yes. Since 01.09.2023, mandatory mediation applies to disputes arising from lease relationships, including eviction lawsuits for breach of contract.
Can neighbours sue the tenant?
Neighbours cannot file an eviction lawsuit under Article 316, but they can request judicial intervention under Article 33 of the Condominium Law to stop the tenant’s disturbing conduct.
In evicting a tenant who disturbs neighbours or damages the property, the outcome is often determined less by the incident itself than by the procedure followed. As the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal decision shows, failing to give a thirty-day notice can lead to the dismissal of an apparently justified claim. Immediate termination should only be used in serious cases that reach the threshold of unbearableness and are supported by concrete evidence. To avoid losing your rights in a specific dispute, it is advisable to consult a lawyer experienced in this field.
Sources: Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Art. 316; Condominium Law No. 634, Arts. 18, 33; Law No. 6325 on Mediation in Civil Disputes, Art. 18/B; Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Art. 4; Ankara BAM 15th Civil Chamber E. 2026/18 K. 2026/2687 and the Court of Cassation decisions listed in the table above. Legislation texts: mevzuat.gov.tr.
Legal Notice: This text has been prepared for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. sophoshukuk.com makes no referral, guarantee or promise of outcome. Each case must be assessed on its own particular circumstances; for your specific dispute, please obtain professional advice from a lawyer.