Att. Hüseyin Aydın · Alanya / Antalya
One morning you see a sheet of paper posted on the entrance door of your apartment building: “Risky structure determination report.” Or perhaps you never see it at all, because the paper got wet in the rain, someone took it down, or you were at your summer house that week. No official letter reaches you either. Yet under the law, this determination may be deemed served on you, and your time limit to object may already have started running.
Urban transformation, which has accelerated across Turkey after the earthquakes, directly affects thousands of right holders in areas with a dense stock of older buildings, such as Alanya, Antalya, Gazipaşa and Mahmutlar. The designation of a building as a risky structure may result in an annotation being entered in the land registry, eviction, demolition and even the sale of the land shares of owners who do not participate. Knowing the time limits and the available objection routes is therefore the first step in protecting your property.
In this guide, the subject is examined in light of Law No. 6306 on the Transformation of Areas under Disaster Risk (Afet Riski Altındaki Alanların Dönüştürülmesi Hakkında Kanun), Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577 (İdari Yargılama Usulü Kanunu) (İYUK) and the decisions of the Council of State (Danıştay).
Contents
- How Are You Notified of the Determination? A Letter May Never Arrive
- Time Limits You Need to Know
- Objection to the Technical Committee
- Action before the Administrative Court
- On What Grounds Can a Risky Structure Report Be Challenged?
- If the Determination Becomes Final: Demolition, Eviction and Absolute Majority
- Tenants and Other Right Holders
- Step-by-Step Roadmap
1. How Are You Notified of the Determination? A Letter May Never Arrive
The second paragraph of Article 3 of Law No. 6306 was amended in 2023 by Law No. 7471, significantly changing the notification procedure. Accordingly, when a structure is determined to be risky:
- The determination is notified to the land registry directorate to be entered in the declarations section of the land register.
- A report containing the details of the determination is posted on the building.
- The owners are notified via the e-Government Gateway (e-Devlet).
- The determination is announced at the relevant neighbourhood headman’s office (muhtarlık) for 15 days.
In the express wording of the Law, the risky structure determination is deemed served on holders of real and personal rights on the last day of the announcement at the headman’s office. In other words, no notification by hand or by post is required. If you do not check your e-Government notifications or do not live in the building, the time limits may start running without your knowledge.
Note: Especially for owners who live in another city, have let the property or use it as a summer home, it is very important to check e-Government notifications regularly and to monitor the declarations in the land register record.
2. Time Limits You Need to Know
| Step | Time limit | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| Announcement at the headman’s office | 15 days (the last day is deemed the date of service) | Law No. 6306, Art. 3/2 |
| Objection to the risky structure determination | 15 days | Law No. 6306, Art. 3/1 |
| Action against administrative acts | 30 days from service | Law No. 6306, Art. 6/9 |
| Period given to the owner to have the building demolished | Maximum 90 days | Law No. 6306, Art. 5/3 |
| Announcement of the eviction and demolition decision | 15 days at the headman’s office (the last day is deemed the date of service) | Law No. 6306, Art. 5/5 |
As can be seen, instead of the general 60-day time limit for bringing an action in administrative jurisdiction, Law No. 6306 provides for a special 30-day time limit. However, the Assembly for the Unification of Case Law of the Council of State (Danıştay İçtihatları Birleştirme Kurulu) has ruled that where the time limit for bringing an action is not stated in an act notified in writing, the general time limit must apply (Council of State Assembly for the Unification of Case Law, E. 2021/2, K. 2022/1, T. 15.03.2022). In a case concerning a risky area decision, the 4th Chamber of the Council of State likewise accepted that the general 60-day time limit had to be applied because the special 30-day limit was not expressly indicated in the act (Council of State 4th Chamber, E. 2023/11411, K. 2023/5787, T. 26.10.2023).
Still, it is risky to wait in reliance on this case law. When calculating time limits, the shortest limit should always be taken as the basis.
3. Objection to the Technical Committee
Owners or their legal representatives may object to the risky structure determination within 15 days. Under the Law, these objections are examined and decided by technical committees composed of four faculty members appointed from the relevant professional disciplines of universities and three persons serving at the Ministry or the Presidency (Law No. 6306, Art. 3/1).
The right to object may be exercised by owners and their legal representatives. According to the provision of the Implementing Regulation cited in Council of State decisions, objections not filed in time or filed by persons other than the owners are not processed. In practice, objections may also result in the technical committee finding the report incomplete and having the licensed institution correct it (Istanbul Regional Administrative Court (İstanbul Bölge İdare Mahkemesi) 6th Administrative Chamber, E. 2020/171, K. 2020/653, T. 13.07.2020).
4. Action before the Administrative Court
Is an objection mandatory?
No. The Plenary of the Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State (Danıştay İdari Dava Daireleri Kurulu) has expressly accepted that objecting to a risky structure determination is an optional right. According to the Plenary’s decision, the act becomes enforceable once the risky structure annotation is entered in the land register and begins to affect the interests of those concerned. Owners may therefore object within fifteen days or bring an action directly. Nor is there any provision in the legislation stating that, if an objection is filed, no action may be brought until the objection is decided (Council of State Plenary of the Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2019/1187, K. 2021/1577, T. 23.09.2021).
This decision is very important in practice. It can eliminate the risk of missing the time limit for bringing an action while waiting for the technical committee to decide on the objection.
Stay of execution
The second sentence of the ninth paragraph of Article 6 of Law No. 6306 was annulled by the Constitutional Court (Anayasa Mahkemesi) (Constitutional Court, E. 2012/87, K. 2014/41, T. 27.02.2014). In its current form, the paragraph contains no provision prohibiting a stay of execution in actions brought against acts under this Law. Accordingly, a stay of execution may be requested in the action under the general rules of the İYUK. Where the demolition date is approaching, this request is of vital importance.
5. On What Grounds Can a Risky Structure Report Be Challenged?
Whether a building is risky is a technical question. For this reason, court decisions focus on whether the report was prepared in accordance with scientific and technical rules:
- Expert examination is required: Since whether a structure is risky cannot be resolved with legal knowledge alone, it was found incorrect for the first-instance court to decide on the case file without an on-site inspection and expert examination (Istanbul Regional Administrative Court 4th Administrative Chamber, E. 2017/1392, K. 2017/1347, T. 29.12.2017).
- Incorrect identification of the building material and lack of analysis: Technical errors such as misidentifying the material of the load-bearing system or preparing the report without a structural analysis are among the main grounds for the unlawfulness of a report. However, these errors must be raised before the determination becomes final; see the warning below.
- Method of examination: The calculation method used in the report, the number of columns from which samples were taken and whether an on-site inspection was carried out are issues frequently debated in proceedings.
The key warning: if the time limit is missed, a challenge to the demolition may also fail. In a case in Edirne, the administrative court, relying on an expert report, found that a structure whose load-bearing system was stone and brick had been assessed as mud-mortar adobe and that no structural analysis had been carried out, and it annulled the demolition decision. The Regional Administrative Court reversed this decision. Its reasoning was as follows: since the owner had not objected to the risky structure determination, the determination had become final. Therefore, in the action brought against the demolition act, there was no need to re-examine whether the structure was risky. The action was dismissed with final effect (Istanbul Regional Administrative Court 6th Administrative Chamber, E. 2019/1771, K. 2020/22, T. 08.01.2020).
The Law lists preparing a report without an on-site technical inspection, or making calculations based on incomplete or incorrect data about the structure, among the acts for which licensed institutions are subject to an administrative fine (Law No. 6306, Art. 3/8). This provision is an important basis for questioning how the report was prepared.
6. If the Determination Becomes Final: Demolition, Eviction and Absolute Majority
- Demolition period: Owners are given a period not exceeding ninety days to have the structure demolished. They are notified that if it is not demolished within this period, it will be demolished by the administrative authorities, and the eviction and demolition are carried out or arranged by the local civil administrators (Law No. 6306, Art. 5/3).
- Costs: The costs of determination, eviction and demolition carried out or arranged by the administration are collected from the owners in proportion to their shares under Law No. 6183 (Law No. 6306, Art. 5/4).
- Absolute majority decision: Matters such as reconstruction and construction in exchange for flats are decided by an absolute majority of the co-owners in proportion to their shares (Law No. 6306, Art. 6/1).
- Share of a non-participating owner: The land shares of owners who do not participate in the decision taken by absolute majority may be sold by auction to the other co-owners who have reached agreement, at a price not lower than market value. The decision and the offer are notified to the non-participating owners through a notary or by announcement at the headman’s office for 15 days. They are warned that if the offer is not accepted within 15 days of notification, their land share will be sold (Law No. 6306, Art. 6/1).
7. Tenants and Other Right Holders
Owners and tenants of structures vacated by agreement, and holders of limited real rights provided they reside in the structure, may be allocated temporary housing or business premises or be granted rent assistance (Law No. 6306, Art. 5/1). Tenants should bear in mind that eviction and demolition notices may also be deemed served by announcement at the headman’s office (Law No. 6306, Art. 5/5).
8. Step-by-Step Roadmap
- Establish the dates. Determine the dates on which the report was posted on the building, the e-Government notification arrived and the announcement at the headman’s office began. Ask the headman’s office in writing for the announcement date.
- Obtain the full report. Request the risky structure determination report, together with its annexes and calculation outputs, from the relevant administration.
- Get an independent technical opinion. Have the report reviewed by a civil engineer. Shortcomings in matters such as the number of samples, identification of materials and the method of analysis form the basis of the objection and the action.
- Object within 15 days. Submit your objection petition to the authority indicated in the report or notification or, if none is indicated, to the provincial directorate of environment, urbanisation and climate change in the province where the building is located, and obtain a receipt. If the time limit is missed, the determination becomes final, and technical errors in the report may not be heard later in an action brought against the demolition act.
- Do not miss the time limit for bringing an action. You are not obliged to wait for the outcome of the objection. Taking the shortest limit of 30 days as the basis, consider bringing an action before the administrative court and requesting a stay of execution.
- Stay in contact with the other flat owners. Respond in time to offers received in the context of absolute majority decisions and land share sales.
Conclusion
A risky structure determination is an administrative process that decides the future of a building and is subject to very short time limits. Since the 2023 amendments, notification is largely made through announcement at the headman’s office and via e-Government, so time limits expiring without the owners’ knowledge has become a real risk. The Council of State’s recognition of the objection as an optional right, keeping the route of a direct action open, is an important safeguard for owners who wish to protect their property.
Whether a determination complies with the law and with technical rules must be assessed separately in each case. To avoid any loss of rights in specific disputes, it is advisable to consult a lawyer experienced in this field.
Sources: Law No. 6306 on the Transformation of Areas under Disaster Risk, Arts. 3, 5, 6 (as amended by Law No. 7471); Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577 (İYUK); Constitutional Court E. 2012/87 K. 2014/41; Council of State Assembly for the Unification of Case Law E. 2021/2 K. 2022/1; Council of State Plenary of the Administrative Law Chambers E. 2019/1187 K. 2021/1577; Council of State 4th Chamber E. 2023/11411 K. 2023/5787; Istanbul Regional Administrative Court 4th Administrative Chamber E. 2017/1392 K. 2017/1347; Istanbul Regional Administrative Court 6th Administrative Chamber E. 2020/171 K. 2020/653; E. 2019/1771 K. 2020/22. For legislation texts: mevzuat.gov.tr.
Legal Notice: This text has been prepared for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. As sophoshukuk.com, we make no referral, guarantee or promise of results. Each case must be assessed according to its own specific circumstances; for your specific disputes, be sure to obtain professional support from a lawyer.