Attorney Hüseyin Aydın · Alanya / Antalya
A rear-end collision on Atatürk Boulevard in Alanya’s summer traffic, a junction crash in Oba or a parked car hit in Mahmutlar… Even if your car is repaired after an accident that was not your fault, on the second-hand market it is now a “damage-recorded” vehicle and its sale value has dropped. This difference is called diminished value (araç değer kaybı), and it is a compensation item most car owners never claim.
Short answer: Diminished value is claimed by a written application to the compulsory traffic insurer of the at-fault party; if there is no reply within 15 days or the offer is insufficient, you can apply to the Insurance Arbitration Commission or file a lawsuit (Highway Traffic Law, Art. 97). According to the Court of Cassation, diminished value is the difference between the car’s undamaged second-hand market value on the accident date and its second-hand market value after repair; the formulas in the insurance general conditions cannot be applied on their own.
Important: The time limit is two years from learning of the damage and the liable person, and in any case ten years from the accident (Art. 109). Any release signed when settling with the insurer should cover only the repair cost; otherwise you risk being deemed to have waived the diminished value claim as well.
In Alanya, Antalya, Gazipaşa, Manavgat, Mahmutlar and Konaklı, accidents with property damage are very frequent due to rental cars, motorcycles and tourist traffic. This guide examines the subject under the Highway Traffic Law No. 2918 and the settled case law of the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation.
Contents
- What Is Diminished Value?
- Against Whom Is the Claim Made?
- How Does the Court of Cassation Calculate Diminished Value?
- Factors Affecting Diminished Value
- Loss of Use and Other Heads of Damage
- Insurance Claim, Arbitration or Lawsuit
- What to Do, Step by Step
- Diminished Value in Academic Research
- Frequently Asked Questions
Anahtar terimler · Key terms · Ключевые термины · واژههای کلیدی
| Türkçe | English | Русский | فارسی |
|---|---|---|---|
| Araç değer kaybı | diminished value of a vehicle | утрата товарной стоимости автомобиля | افت ارزش خودرو |
| Hasar bedeli | repair cost | стоимость ремонта | هزینه تعمیر |
| Araç mahrumiyet bedeli | loss of use compensation | компенсация за невозможность пользоваться авто | غرامت محرومیت از خودرو |
| Sigorta Tahkim Komisyonu | Insurance Arbitration Commission | Страховая арбитражная комиссия | کمیسیون داوری بیمه |
| Kusur raporu | fault report | заключение о виновности | گزارش تقصیر |
| Alanya trafik kazası avukatı | Alanya car accident lawyer | адвокат по ДТП в Аланье | وکیل تصادفات در آلانیا |
1. What Is Diminished Value?
The Court of Cassation defines diminished value as follows:
Diminished value concerns the difference between the value of the vehicle after it has been damaged in a traffic accident and repaired, and its value had it never been damaged (…)
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/12979, K. 2022/14487, 14.11.2022 (unofficial translation)
Diminished value is a separate head of damage from the repair cost. Even if the car is repaired perfectly, the price second-hand buyers are willing to pay drops because of the damage record and repair traces. This difference is the responsibility of the at-fault party and its insurer.
2. Against Whom Is the Claim Made?
- The at-fault vehicle’s compulsory traffic insurer: liable within the per-vehicle property damage limit in the policy and in proportion to the insured’s fault. In practice this is the first and most important counterparty.
- The at-fault driver and the vehicle’s operator (keeper): liable for damage exceeding the insurance limit and for items outside cover (e.g. loss of use). The operator is liable for the driver’s fault as for its own (Art. 85).
- Guarantee Fund: if the at-fault vehicle was uninsured or cannot be identified, a claim can be made within the statutory limits.
- Road authority: if the accident was caused by a road defect (e.g. an unmarked open manhole), the responsible authority may also be liable. The Court of Cassation has held that such a case is heard by the ordinary civil courts (reversal decision cited in 4th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/12979, K. 2022/14487).
Your own comprehensive (kasko) policy does not, as a rule, cover diminished value; even if kasko pays for the repair, you must apply separately to the other party’s traffic insurer for diminished value.
3. How Does the Court of Cassation Calculate Diminished Value?
Insurers mostly calculate diminished value using the formula annexed to the Traffic Insurance General Conditions, which usually gives low results. The 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, however, consistently applies this principle:
Diminished value must be calculated by determining the second-hand market value of the vehicle in undamaged condition on the accident date under free market conditions and, taking into account the vehicle’s age, features, the amount of damage and the nature of the damaged parts, its market value in repaired condition after the accident, and then taking the decrease between these two amounts.
Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/24132, K. 2023/8841, 12.07.2023 (unofficial translation)
The Court repeated this approach when reversing a decision in which the Insurance Arbitration Commission had awarded the amount calculated by the general conditions formula (4th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/2945, K. 2025/6015, 16.04.2025). Likewise, it held that no judgment can be based on expert reports that determine diminished value by a “general assessment” instead of the market difference (4th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/2224, K. 2025/15472, 19.11.2025).
4. Factors Affecting Diminished Value
- Make, model, age and mileage: diminished value is generally higher for new, low-mileage cars.
- Location and nature of the damage: damage to fixed (welded) parts and the chassis causes higher diminished value than damage to bolted parts. In a file reviewed by the Court of Cassation, the expert expressly made this distinction (4th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/2959, K. 2025/8819, 29.05.2025).
- Previous damage records: earlier damage to the same part may reduce diminished value, so the car’s damage history is examined.
- Replacement with original parts: does not by itself eliminate diminished value. The Court reversed a decision that rejected the claim on the grounds that “parts will be replaced with original spare parts” and “it is not body panelling, there is no damage record”, because the market-difference criterion had not been applied (E. 2022/12979, K. 2022/14487).
5. Loss of Use and Other Heads of Damage
In addition to diminished value, the following can also be claimed:
- Repair cost: if kasko did not pay, it is claimed directly from the other party’s traffic insurer.
- Loss of use: the damage from not being able to use the car during a reasonable repair period. The Court of Cassation has held that this claim cannot be rejected merely because no car rental document was submitted, and that loss of use should be awarded after determining a reasonable repair period and deducting necessary expenses (E. 2022/12979, K. 2022/14487). However, as this is indirect damage, it falls outside compulsory traffic insurance cover and is claimed from the driver and operator (reversal decision cited in 4th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/20376, K. 2022/5342).
- Necessary expenses such as the appraisal fee and towing costs.
6. Insurance Claim, Arbitration or Lawsuit
Under Art. 97 of the Highway Traffic Law, a written application to the other party’s traffic insurer is mandatory before suing or going to arbitration. Attach the accident report, vehicle registration, driving licence, damage photos, repair invoice and any appraisal report. If the insurer does not respond within 15 days or the offer is insufficient:
- Insurance Arbitration Commission: frequently preferred for diminished value disputes thanks to the low application fee and relatively fast process. Objection and appeal routes are open against arbitral decisions above certain monetary thresholds.
- Court: actions against insurers are as a rule heard by the commercial court of first instance. If the car owner acts as a consumer, the competent court should be assessed separately.
7. What to Do, Step by Step
- Complete an accident report or obtain a police/gendarmerie report, and make sure fault is recorded correctly.
- Photograph the damage and document the condition before and after repair.
- Keep the repair invoice and parts list; which parts were replaced and which were painted is decisive in calculating diminished value.
- Apply in writing to the other party’s insurer and keep proof of the application date.
- Assess the offer; against low offers based on the general conditions formula, an independent appraisal using the market-difference method can be obtained.
- Sign the release carefully and, if necessary, go to arbitration or court.
8. Diminished Value in Academic Research
Diminished value has become an important topic in Turkish postgraduate insurance law research. A master’s thesis in the Council of Higher Education (YÖK) National Thesis Centre examines the calculation methods for damage and diminished value under traffic insurance, addresses the long-standing normative conflict between administrative regulations and the case law of the high courts, and assesses the applicability of the principle of actual damage in light of the situation as it stood in 2025 (Erdoğan, 2026, Thesis No. 993336). A doctoral thesis devoted to determining diminished value under compulsory liability insurance examines how the concept of damage has expanded over time to cover situations previously not regarded as damage, and how diminished value is to be determined in that framework (Çorbacıoğlu Aydoğmuş, 2023, Thesis No. 803240).
Another, practice-oriented thesis stresses that accident reports, photos of the damage and after repair, the repair shop and the parts used are important in determining diminished value, and that the calculation is made by appraisers and experts because it requires technical knowledge (Akıncı, 2022, Thesis No. 795753). This also explains why the documents in the step-by-step list above should be kept in full.
Conclusion
Diminished value is a separate and often overlooked head of damage, distinct from the repair cost. The claim is first made to the other party’s compulsory traffic insurer; according to the Court of Cassation, the calculation is based not on insurance formulas but on the difference between the car’s second-hand market values before the accident and after repair. Items outside insurance cover, such as loss of use, can be claimed from the driver and operator.
As insurers’ offers may not cover the actual loss and the two-year time limit is short, for your specific dispute and to avoid losing rights, it is advisable to consult a lawyer specialised in this field.
Frequently Asked Questions
From whom is diminished value claimed?
Primarily from the at-fault vehicle’s compulsory traffic insurer, within the policy limit and the fault ratio. The at-fault driver and the vehicle operator are liable for damage exceeding the limit and for items outside cover.
How is diminished value calculated?
According to the Court of Cassation, the basis is the difference between the car’s undamaged second-hand market value on the accident date and its second-hand market value after repair, taking into account age, mileage, model and the nature of the damaged parts.
Does my own kasko pay diminished value?
As a rule, no. Even if kasko covers the repair, you must apply separately to the at-fault party’s traffic insurer for diminished value.
How long do I have to claim diminished value?
Under Art. 109 of the Highway Traffic Law, within two years of learning of the damage and the liable person, and in any case within ten years of the accident.
Can I get compensation for the time my car was in the garage?
Yes, loss of use can be claimed. The Court of Cassation has held that it should be calculated on a reasonable repair period and that the absence of a car rental document is not by itself a reason to reject it. This item is outside traffic insurance cover and is claimed from the driver and operator.
Is there diminished value if parts were replaced with original parts?
There can be. The Court of Cassation has held that a claim cannot be rejected simply because original parts were used or no damage record was created; the market difference must be determined by an expert.
Sources: Highway Traffic Law No. 2918 Arts. 85, 97, 109; Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 Arts. 49 et seq.; Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber E. 2021/24132 K. 2023/8841; E. 2025/2945 K. 2025/6015; E. 2024/2224 K. 2025/15472; E. 2022/12979 K. 2022/14487; E. 2023/2959 K. 2025/8819; E. 2021/20376 K. 2022/5342; E. 2023/6051 K. 2023/9990; YÖK National Thesis Centre Nos. 993336, 803240, 795753. Legislation texts: mevzuat.gov.tr.
Legal Notice: This text has been prepared for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. sophoshukuk.com makes no referral, guarantee or promise of outcome. Each case must be assessed on its own particular circumstances; for your specific dispute, please obtain professional advice from a lawyer.